Moral luck is a philosophical concept that explores the relationship between moral judgment and factors outside an individual’s control. The idea of moral luck highlights the fact that individuals can be held morally responsible for outcomes they did not intentionally cause, and that factors outside of their control can influence how they are judged by society.
The concept of moral luck was introduced by philosopher Bernard Williams in the late 20th century. Williams argued that moral responsibility is not only determined by an individual’s intentions and actions but also by external factors such as luck, chance, and circumstances.
There are four types of moral luck:
- Resultant Luck – This refers to the moral judgment that is based on the outcome of an action, which is often influenced by factors beyond an individual’s control. For example, a surgeon may be considered a hero for successfully saving a patient’s life, while another surgeon who performs the same procedure but loses the patient may be criticized, despite both doctors having made the same effort and using the same skillset.
- Circumstantial Luck – This refers to the moral judgment that is based on an individual’s circumstances. For example, a person born into a wealthy family may be considered successful and hardworking, while a person born into poverty may be considered a failure, even if they work just as hard.
- Constitutive Luck – This refers to the moral judgment that is based on an individual’s innate abilities, talents, and characteristics. For example, a person who is naturally intelligent may be praised for their achievements, while a person who struggles academically due to a learning disability may be viewed as lazy or unmotivated.
- Causal luck refers to the outcomes or events in one’s life that are influenced by factors outside of their control, such as chance or external circumstances. It is a type of luck that is not directly attributable to an individual’s actions or choices, but rather the result of a combination of factors beyond their control.