Socialization versus Enculturation

Socialization and enculturation are two related but distinct processes through which individuals learn the customs, values, beliefs, and norms of their society. Both processes are important for the development of an individual’s social identity and their ability to navigate social interactions. However, there are some key differences between the two concepts.

Socialization refers to the process through which individuals learn the social norms, values, and expectations of their culture. It is a lifelong process that begins in infancy and continues throughout an individual’s life. Socialization occurs through various agents of socialization such as family, peers, education, and media. These agents help individuals learn the norms and values of their society and how to behave in social situations.

Enculturation, on the other hand, refers to the process through which individuals learn the culture of their society. It is a more comprehensive process that includes socialization as a component. Enculturation involves learning the beliefs, customs, traditions, and practices that define a culture. This process helps individuals acquire an understanding of the world around them and their place in it.

One way to distinguish between socialization and enculturation is to think of socialization as a means to an end and enculturation as the end itself. Socialization is a process that helps individuals acquire the skills and knowledge necessary to function within their culture. Enculturation, on the other hand, is about understanding and embracing the culture itself.

Another difference between socialization and enculturation is that socialization is often focused on the individual, while enculturation is focused on the culture as a whole. Socialization helps individuals develop the skills and knowledge they need to interact with others in their culture. Enculturation, however, helps individuals understand the broader social, political, and economic systems that shape their culture.

While socialization and enculturation are related processes, they are not always in sync. For example, an individual may be socialized to value individualism and independence, but their culture may place a higher value on collectivism and interdependence. In this case, the individual may experience conflict between their socialization and their enculturation. Such conflicts can create a sense of cultural dissonance, where an individual feel disconnected from their culture.

In conclusion, socialization and enculturation are two important processes through which individuals learn the norms, values, beliefs, and customs of their society. While socialization is focused on developing individual skills and knowledge, enculturation is about understanding and embracing the broader culture. Both processes are essential for the development of an individual’s social identity and their ability to navigate social interactions. However, conflicts between an individual’s socialization and enculturation can create a sense of cultural dissonance.

Socialization versus Enculturation

Meaning, Purpose, and Agents of Socialization

Meaning of Socialization

Socialization refers to the process by which individuals learn and internalize the values, norms, beliefs, and behaviors of their culture or society. It is the process of learning and acquiring the social skills necessary to become a functioning member of a community. Socialization occurs throughout a person’s lifetime, beginning in childhood and continuing into adulthood.

During childhood, socialization occurs primarily through interactions with parents, family members, and other adults, as well as through exposure to various media and social institutions such as schools and religious organizations. As children grow older, they also begin to interact more with their peers, which further shapes their understanding of social norms and values.

Socialization serves several important functions in society. It helps individuals develop a sense of self-identity and understand their place in society. It also helps them to learn how to communicate effectively with others, to follow social norms and rules, and to develop empathy and understanding towards others.

There are several agents of socialization that contribute to the process of socialization. These include family, peers, schools, religious institutions, the media, and the workplace. Each of these agents plays a unique role in shaping an individual’s understanding of social norms and values.

In addition to the agents of socialization, there are also different types of socialization. Primary socialization occurs during childhood and involves learning the basic skills and values necessary to become a functioning member of society. Secondary socialization occurs later in life and involves learning new skills and values that are specific to particular roles or situations, such as entering a new profession or joining a new social group.

Purpose of Socialization

The purpose of socialization is to ensure that individuals learn and internalize the norms, values, and expectations of their culture or society. This process helps individuals to become functioning members of society, capable of interacting with others and contributing to the collective well-being of their community.

The purpose of socialization can be understood through several key functions that it serves in society. These include:

Establishing social norms and values: Socialization helps to establish the shared beliefs and values that define a particular culture or society. These norms and values shape how individuals perceive the world around them and what they consider to be acceptable behavior.

Transmitting culture: Socialization is how culture is transmitted from one generation to the next. It ensures that individuals learn the customs, traditions, and practices that are important to their community, and helps to maintain cultural continuity over time.

Creating social order: Socialization plays a vital role in creating and maintaining social order. By establishing and reinforcing social norms and values, socialization ensures that individuals understand their roles and responsibilities within the community, and behave in ways that are consistent with the expectations of others.

Facilitating social interaction: Socialization provides individuals with the skills and knowledge necessary to interact with others in a social setting. It helps individuals to understand how to communicate effectively, to interpret social cues, and to navigate the complexities of social relationships.

Fostering personal development: Socialization is also critical for personal development. It helps individuals to develop a sense of self-identity, to understand their place in society, and to develop the skills and abilities necessary to succeed in life.

Agents of Socialization

There are several agents of socialization that contribute to the process of socialization. These agents include family, peers, schools, religious institutions, the media, and the workplace. Each of these agents plays a unique role in shaping an individual’s understanding of social norms and values.

Family is often considered the most important agent of socialization, as it is the primary source of socialization for children during their early years. Parents and other family members help to shape a child’s values, beliefs, and behaviors through direct instruction, modeling, and reinforcement.

Peers also play an important role in socialization, particularly during adolescence. Peer groups provide a context in which individuals can experiment with different behaviors and roles, and learn to navigate complex social relationships.

Schools are another critical agent of socialization, as they provide individuals with the knowledge and skills necessary to function in society. Schools not only teach academic subjects but also social skills, such as how to work collaboratively with others, how to follow rules and procedures, and how to respect authority.

Religious institutions also play an important role in socialization, particularly in shaping an individual’s moral and ethical beliefs. Religious institutions provide individuals with a sense of community and belonging, as well as a framework for understanding the world around them.

The media, including television, movies, and social media, also plays a significant role in shaping the attitudes, beliefs, and values of individuals. The media can both reflect and shape social norms and values, and can provide individuals with a window into other cultures and ways of life.

Finally, the workplace is an important agent of socialization for adults. Through work, individuals learn the skills and values necessary to succeed in a particular profession or industry, as well as the expectations and norms of the workplace culture.

What is Socialization

What is Conflict Theory?

Conflict theory is a sociological theory that seeks to explain the nature of society and social relationships. It posits that society is characterized by conflicts and tensions between different groups of people who have different interests and values. These conflicts arise from the unequal distribution of power, wealth, and resources in society, and they are perpetuated by social institutions that serve the interests of the dominant group. Conflict theory was first articulated by Karl Marx in the mid-19th century, and it has since been developed and expanded upon by other sociologists and theorists.

Basic Concepts

At the heart of conflict theory is the idea that society is divided into different classes or groups that have conflicting interests. These groups are defined by their relationship to the means of production, or the resources and tools necessary for producing goods and services. The dominant group, or the bourgeoisie, owns and controls the means of production, while the subordinate group, or the proletariat, is exploited by the bourgeoisie to produce goods and services for their own profit.

According to conflict theory, the relationship between these two groups is characterized by a struggle for power and resources. The bourgeoisie use their wealth and power to maintain their dominance over the proletariat, while the proletariat use their labor to resist exploitation and achieve greater economic and political equality. This struggle is the engine that drives social change, as the subordinate group seeks to overthrow the dominant group and establish a more equal and just society.

Key Concepts

There are several key concepts that are central to conflict theory:

Power: Power is the ability to influence or control the behavior of others. In conflict theory, power is concentrated in the hands of the dominant group, who use it to maintain their position of privilege and suppress the aspirations of the subordinate group.

Exploitation: Exploitation refers to the process by which the dominant group extracts value from the labor of the subordinate group without providing fair compensation. In conflict theory, the dominant group exploits the labor of the subordinate group to generate profits and maintain their position of power.

Class consciousness: Class consciousness refers to the awareness that members of the subordinate group have of their shared economic and political interests. In conflict theory, the development of class consciousness is an important step in the struggle for social change, as it allows the subordinate group to recognize the source of their exploitation and unite in opposition to the dominant group.

Social institutions: Social institutions, such as government, education, and the media, are organized in a way that reflects and reinforces the interests of the dominant group. In conflict theory, social institutions are seen as tools of the dominant group, used to maintain their position of power and suppress the aspirations of the subordinate group.

Critiques

Conflict theory has been criticized for a number of reasons. One of the main criticisms is that it focuses too heavily on conflict and ignores the many ways in which people and groups cooperate and work together to achieve common goals. Some critics argue that conflict theory is too simplistic in its characterization of society as a battleground between two opposing groups, and that it does not adequately account for the many nuances and complexities of social relationships.

Another criticism of conflict theory is that it places too much emphasis on economic factors and ignores the role of cultural, political, and social factors in shaping social relationships. Some critics argue that culture, ideology, and identity are just as important as economic factors in shaping social relationships, and that conflict theory’s focus on economic factors ignores these other important factors.

Finally, conflict theory has been criticized for its deterministic view of social change. Some critics argue that conflict theory assumes that social change is inevitable and that the subordinate group will inevitably overthrow the dominant group. However, history has shown that social change is not always a straightforward process, and that the struggle for social justice is often long and difficult.

Brief History of Sociology

Sociology is the study of human society, social behavior, and social institutions. It is a relatively new field of study that emerged in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, with the rise of industrialization, urbanization, and the Enlightenment. In this essay, I will provide a brief history of sociology, from its origins to its present-day status as a vital discipline within the social sciences.

The origins of sociology can be traced back to the work of several social thinkers in the 18th and early 19th centuries. These thinkers, who are often referred to as the “fathers” of sociology, include Auguste Comte, Karl Marx, Max Weber, Emile Durkheim, and Herbert Spencer. Each of these thinkers made significant contributions to the development of sociology as a field of study.

Auguste Comte, a French philosopher, coined the term “sociology” in the 1830s. He believed that sociology should be based on empirical observation and that it should be used to create a more just and rational society. Comte’s work laid the foundation for the positivist approach to sociology, which emphasizes the use of scientific methods to study social phenomena.

Karl Marx, a German philosopher, is best known for his theory of historical materialism, which argues that social and economic conditions are the primary drivers of historical change. Marx believed that capitalism was inherently exploitative and that workers would eventually overthrow the capitalist system. His work laid the foundation for the Marxist approach to sociology, which emphasizes the importance of social class and economic structures in shaping social phenomena.

Max Weber, a German sociologist, is best known for his theory of bureaucracy and his concept of the “ideal type.” Weber argued that bureaucracy was a rational and efficient way to organize society, but he also recognized that it could lead to alienation and dehumanization. His work laid the foundation for the interpretive approach to sociology, which emphasizes the subjective meanings that individuals attach to social phenomena.

Emile Durkheim, a French sociologist, is best known for his theory of social integration and his concept of “anomie.” Durkheim argued that social integration was essential for a healthy society and that anomie, or the breakdown of social norms, could lead to social disintegration. His work laid the foundation for the functionalist approach to sociology, which emphasizes the importance of social institutions in maintaining social order.

Herbert Spencer, an English philosopher, is best known for his theory of social Darwinism, which applied Darwin’s theory of natural selection to human society. Spencer believed that social progress was driven by the survival of the fittest and that societies would naturally evolve toward greater complexity and organization. His work laid the foundation for the evolutionary approach to sociology, which emphasizes the historical development of social structures and institutions.

In the early 20th century, sociology became an established academic discipline, with the founding of the first sociology departments in Europe and the United States. The discipline continued to develop and expand throughout the 20th century, with the emergence of new theoretical perspectives and research methods.

One important development in the history of sociology was the rise of the Chicago School in the early 20th century. The Chicago School was a group of sociologists who focused on the study of urban life and the social problems associated with urbanization. They used ethnographic methods to study the lives of ordinary people and to understand the social dynamics of urban neighborhoods. The Chicago School had a significant influence on the development of symbolic interactionism, a theoretical perspective that emphasizes the importance of symbols and meanings in social life.

What is Cultural Diffusion?

Cultural diffusion is the spread of cultural traits, ideas, and practices from one culture to another. This process can occur through a variety of mechanisms, including migration, trade, media, and technology. Cultural diffusion can have both positive and negative effects on societies, depending on the specific cultural traits being diffused and the context in which they are adopted.

One example of cultural diffusion is the spread of Western culture around the world. This process has been facilitated by the global reach of Western media, technology, and trade networks. Western cultural traits such as music, fashion, and consumerism have become popular in many parts of the world, often displacing or altering local cultural practices.

Another example of cultural diffusion is the spread of Buddhism from India to other parts of Asia. Buddhism originated in India in the 6th century BCE and gradually spread to other parts of the region, including China, Japan, and Korea. Along the way, it was adapted and transformed by local cultures, leading to the emergence of new forms of Buddhism that reflect local customs and beliefs.

Cultural diffusion can also occur within a single society or culture. For example, the adoption of new technologies or cultural practices can spread rapidly within a society, leading to changes in behavior and social norms. The rise of social media and smartphones, for instance, has had a profound impact on the way people communicate, socialize, and consume information.

Cultural diffusion can have both positive and negative effects on societies. On the positive side, it can lead to the exchange of ideas and cultural practices that enrich and diversify societies. For example, the adoption of new foods or musical styles from other cultures can broaden people’s experiences and help to break down cultural barriers.

On the negative side, cultural diffusion can also lead to cultural imperialism, where dominant cultures impose their values and practices on weaker cultures. This can lead to the erosion of local traditions and the loss of cultural diversity. It can also create tensions and conflicts between different groups as they struggle to maintain their cultural identity in the face of outside influences.

Cultural diffusion can also have unintended consequences. For example, the adoption of new technologies or practices can lead to unintended environmental or social impacts. The spread of Western-style consumerism, for instance, has contributed to unsustainable levels of resource consumption and environmental degradation in many parts of the world.

Overall, cultural diffusion is a complex and ongoing process that shapes the evolution of societies and cultures around the world. It is driven by a variety of factors, including technological change, economic globalization, and social and political interactions. While it can have both positive and negative effects, cultural diffusion is an essential aspect of human societies, allowing for the exchange of ideas, practices, and values that enrich and diversify our cultural heritage.

Cultural Diffusion

What is Counterculture?

Counterculture refers to a cultural movement that challenges or opposes the values, norms, and practices of the dominant culture. Countercultural movements often emerge in response to social, political, or economic conditions that are seen as unjust, oppressive, or unsustainable. These movements may seek to create alternative systems of belief and behavior that challenge the status quo and promote social change.

The term counterculture was first used in the 1960s to describe a range of movements that emerged in response to the Vietnam War, the civil rights movement, and the rise of consumerism. These movements were characterized by their rejection of mainstream values and their embrace of alternative lifestyles, artistic expressions, and political ideologies.

One of the most iconic countercultural movements of the 1960s was the hippie movement. Hippies rejected mainstream values of materialism, conformity, and authority, and embraced peace, love, and communal living. They expressed their values through their clothing, music, art, and activism, and created alternative communities that promoted self-expression, environmentalism, and spiritual exploration.

Another countercultural movement of the 1960s was the Civil Rights Movement. This movement challenged racial segregation, discrimination, and inequality, and sought to promote equal rights and opportunities for all. The Civil Rights Movement used nonviolent resistance, civil disobedience, and legal action to bring about social change, and its impact can still be seen today in the ongoing struggle for racial justice and equity.

Other countercultural movements of the 1960s included the feminist movement, the anti-war movement, and the gay liberation movement. Each of these movements sought to challenge dominant cultural norms and promote social change by advocating for equal rights, social justice, and alternative ways of living.

While countercultural movements can be a powerful force for social change, they can also face opposition and criticism from those who support the status quo. Mainstream society may view countercultural movements as threatening or disruptive, and may use various forms of repression, censorship, or violence to suppress them.

In addition, countercultural movements can also face internal challenges, such as conflicts over goals, tactics, and leadership. These movements may struggle to maintain their unity and momentum over time, and may face challenges in translating their ideals into concrete political or social action.

In conclusion, counterculture refers to a cultural movement that challenges or opposes the values, norms, and practices of the dominant culture. Countercultural movements can emerge in response to social, political, or economic conditions that are seen as unjust or oppressive, and may seek to create alternative systems of belief and behavior that promote social change. While countercultural movements can be a powerful force for social change, they may also face opposition and internal challenges that can limit their effectiveness over time.

Counterculture

What is Subculture?

Subculture refers to a group of individuals who share common interests, values, beliefs, and behaviors that differ from those of the dominant culture. Subcultures can exist within larger cultural groups, and they may arise due to differences in social class, ethnicity, religion, age, gender, or sexuality. In many cases, subcultures form as a way to express individuality, reject mainstream norms, and find a sense of belonging among like-minded individuals.

One of the most defining features of subcultures is their distinct style, which often includes clothing, music, art, and other forms of expression. For example, the punk subculture emerged in the 1970s and was characterized by its anti-establishment attitude, aggressive music, and distinctive fashion. Punks often wore leather jackets, ripped clothing, and spiky hair, and they expressed their dissatisfaction with mainstream society through music that was loud, fast, and rebellious.

Subcultures can also form around shared interests or hobbies, such as sports, gaming, or anime. These subcultures may have their own jargon, rituals, and customs that are unique to their group. For example, fans of a particular sports team may have their own chants, hand signals, and dress codes that set them apart from other fans.

Subcultures can be seen as a way to resist social norms and conventions, and they may be associated with countercultural movements that seek to challenge the status quo. For example, the hippie movement of the 1960s was a subculture that rejected mainstream values and embraced peace, love, and communal living. Hippies often wore tie-dyed clothing, smoked marijuana, and participated in protests against war and social injustice.

Subcultures can also be a way for marginalized groups to find acceptance and support within society. For example, the LGBTQ+ community has formed its own subcultures around shared experiences and identities. These subcultures may include drag queens, leather culture, or ballroom culture, each with its own unique customs and practices.

However, subcultures can also be criticized for promoting exclusivity and limiting diversity within society. Some subcultures may become insular and reject outsiders, leading to a lack of understanding and acceptance between different groups. Additionally, subcultures may reinforce stereotypes and negative attitudes towards marginalized groups.

In conclusion, subculture refers to a group of individuals who share common interests, values, beliefs, and behaviors that differ from those of the dominant culture. Subcultures can form around shared interests or identities and may be a way to resist social norms or find acceptance within society. While subcultures can be a positive force for individuals seeking community and individuality, they can also promote exclusivity and reinforce stereotypes.

Subculture

What is Material Culture?

Material culture refers to the physical objects and artifacts that human beings create, use, and value as a part of their lives. It includes everything from simple tools and utensils to works of art, clothing, architecture, and technology. Material culture is an important aspect of anthropology, archaeology, and sociology, as it provides insights into the beliefs, values, and practices of different societies and cultures.

The study of material culture is concerned with the analysis of the ways in which material objects reflect and shape social and cultural practices. Material culture can be used to understand the ways in which people interact with their environment, the technologies they use, and the ways in which they organize their lives. It also helps us understand the ways in which social relationships are created and maintained through material objects and the ways in which these relationships change over time.

Material culture can be divided into two categories: tangible and intangible. Tangible material culture refers to physical objects such as clothing, furniture, tools, and art, while intangible material culture refers to things like language, folklore, and music. The study of intangible material culture is called folklore studies or ethnology, which deals with cultural traditions and practices that are transmitted orally or through other non-physical means.

One of the key concepts within the study of material culture is the idea of materiality. Materiality refers to the ways in which physical objects are imbued with social and cultural meanings. Objects can be seen as material expressions of culture, reflecting the values, beliefs, and practices of the people who create, use, and exchange them. For example, in some cultures, certain colors or materials may be associated with particular meanings or values, such as the use of gold in many cultures to signify wealth and prosperity.

The study of material culture can provide insights into how societies and cultures change over time. As objects are created, used, and discarded, they can provide evidence of social, economic, and political change. For example, changes in pottery styles can reveal shifts in economic and social relationships, while changes in clothing styles can reveal changes in cultural practices and values.

Material culture can also be used to understand the ways in which power is distributed within societies. Objects can be seen as markers of social status, and their use and possession can be used to signal social hierarchies. For example, in some cultures, certain types of clothing may be reserved for the elite, while others may be reserved for lower classes. Similarly, the possession of certain objects, such as expensive cars or luxury goods, can be used to signal wealth and power.

In conclusion, material culture refers to the physical objects and artifacts that human beings create, use, and value as a part of their lives. It is an important aspect of anthropology, archaeology, and sociology, as it provides insights into the beliefs, values, and practices of different societies and cultures. The study of material culture is concerned with the analysis of the ways in which material objects reflect and shape social and cultural practices. Materiality is a key concept within the study of material culture, and it refers to the ways in which physical objects are imbued with social and cultural meanings. Material culture can provide insights into how societies and cultures change over time and can be used to understand the ways in which power is distributed within societies.

Material Culture

Elements of Culture

Culture can be defined as the shared set of values, beliefs, customs, behaviors, and artifacts that characterize a group or society. It is a complex and multifaceted concept that encompasses many different aspects of human life. In this essay, I will discuss the elements of culture, including language, religion, social organization, art and literature, and technology.

Language is one of the most important elements of culture. It is the primary means by which individuals communicate with one another, express their thoughts and feelings, and share information. Language is a powerful tool that allows people to express their culture and identity. It reflects the values and beliefs of a society and helps to shape the way people think about the world around them. Every culture has its own unique language, with its own vocabulary, grammar, and syntax. Language is also constantly evolving and adapting to changes in society, technology, and globalization.

Religion is another important element of culture. It provides people with a sense of meaning and purpose, helps them to understand their place in the world, and guides their behavior and interactions with others. Religion encompasses a wide range of beliefs, practices, and rituals, and is often closely tied to cultural identity. It can also serve as a source of conflict between different groups or societies, as people may have different beliefs and values that are incompatible with one another.

Social organization is another key element of culture. It refers to the way in which individuals and groups are organized within a society, including the roles they play, the relationships they have with one another, and the institutions that govern their behavior. Social organization can take many different forms, including families, communities, political systems, and economic structures. It is often shaped by cultural values and beliefs, and can vary significantly from one society to another.

Art and literature are also important elements of culture. They provide a means for people to express themselves creatively, and to explore and reflect upon their experiences and emotions. Art and literature can take many different forms, including painting, sculpture, music, poetry, and prose. They are often closely tied to cultural identity, and can serve as a way of preserving and transmitting cultural traditions and values from one generation to the next.

Finally, technology is an increasingly important element of culture. It refers to the tools, techniques, and processes that people use to solve problems, achieve goals, and improve their lives. Technology can take many different forms, including computers, smartphones, transportation systems, and medical devices. It is often driven by economic, political, and social factors, and can have a profound impact on the way people live, work, and interact with one another.

In conclusion, culture is a complex and multifaceted concept that encompasses many different elements. Language, religion, social organization, art and literature, and technology are just a few of the many factors that shape and reflect cultural values and beliefs. By understanding these elements, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the diversity and richness of human culture, and work to build more inclusive and respectful societies that value and celebrate this diversity.

Elements of Culture

Is Culture’s Root Biological or Societal?

The debate about whether culture’s root is biological or societal has been ongoing for years. While both biological and societal factors have an impact on the development of culture, it is difficult to argue that one is more influential than the other. In this essay, we will explore the role of biology and society in shaping culture and argue that the two are interdependent.

Biological factors such as genetics, evolutionary history, and brain function undoubtedly play a role in shaping culture. For example, human beings have an innate predisposition to learn and communicate through language, which is an essential aspect of culture. Moreover, evolutionary pressures have led to the development of certain cultural practices, such as kinship systems and religious rituals, which help to promote social cohesion and group survival.

However, it would be a mistake to assume that culture is solely determined by biology. Instead, culture is shaped by a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and social factors. The environment and social factors, such as family upbringing, education, religion, and political institutions, play an equally critical role in shaping culture.

Societal factors are perhaps the most significant determinants of culture. Society provides a context for cultural expression, and cultural practices are shaped by societal norms, values, and beliefs. For example, the attitudes towards gender and sexuality vary widely across different cultures, and these attitudes are largely determined by societal factors such as religion, history, and politics.

Moreover, culture is not static but constantly evolving, and societal factors are the primary drivers of cultural change. As societies change over time, so do cultural practices and values. For example, the rise of the internet and social media has led to the emergence of new cultural practices, such as online activism and social networking, which would have been impossible in the past.

However, it is important to note that societal factors are not entirely independent of biological factors. Biological factors, such as genetic predispositions and brain function, can influence societal norms and values. For example, research has shown that certain genetic factors can influence behavior and personality traits, which in turn can affect social norms and values.

In addition, the environment plays a crucial role in shaping both biological and societal factors. The physical environment, such as geography and climate, can influence cultural practices, while the social environment, such as family upbringing and education, can influence individual behavior and beliefs.

In conclusion, it is difficult to argue that culture’s root is solely biological or societal. Both biological and societal factors play an essential role in shaping culture, and the two are interdependent. While biological factors provide a foundation for cultural development, societal factors are the primary drivers of cultural change. Ultimately, culture is a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and social factors, and it is the product of the unique histories and circumstances of each society.

error: Content is protected !!